Covid-19 Update: We are continuing to provide our usual services whilst maintaining the safety of clients and colleagues. Read our latest update here.

Complete the form below to ask us a question or make an enquiry. We’ll get back to you via phone or email as soon as possible.

Insights

Pandemic employment claim decisions

Posted on 11th June 2021 in Employment

Posted by

Stephen Jennings

Partner and Solicitor
Pandemic employment claim decisions

We are now starting to see decisions come through for pandemic-related employment claims, such as the recent case of Mr Francesco Accattatis v Fortuna Group (London) Limited.

Mr Accattatis worked for a company which sells PPE. He was uncomfortable attending his place of work (which involved travelling by bus) during lockdown and he could not work from home. Requests for furlough were declined and Mr Accattatis was told if he did not wish to attend work, he could take paid holiday or unpaid leave. In the face of Mr Accattatis’ evident reluctance to attend work, he was dismissed.

Although he did not have the requisite two years’ service to claim ordinary unfair dismissal, Mr Accattatis claimed he had been dismissed for refusing to attend work, which was automatically unfair because:

The Tribunal agreed with Mr Accattatis that there were circumstances of danger which he reasonably believed to be serious and imminent. However his claim failed on the grounds that he was not dismissed for proposing to stay at home (which he could have done by taking leave), but rather for unreasonably demanding to be paid whilst at home (either under the furlough scheme or by working from home).

Whilst only a first instance decision which other Employment Tribunals are not bound to follow, this gives an interesting insight into how Tribunals approach claims of this sort and shows that the pandemic may not on its own justify a refusal to attend work if employers have reasonably tried to accommodate employees' concerns.

 

How can Tozers help?

For further specialist employer support or employment advice, please contact our specialist employment team.

Contact our legal experts


 

Paper plane

 

Get the latest news straight from our legal experts.

Subscribe to our newsletter to recieve current, dedicated, suppport and guidance from our solicitors straight to your inbox, wherever you are.

Company & Industry

Related Insights

Insights

Company directors: are they employees?

Posted on 07th January 2022 in Employment

Whether or not directors are also employees is often not a simple question and can have big implications both for the individual and the company.

Posted by

Stephen Jennings

Partner and Solicitor
Insights

Why you should think twice before running a workplace raffle or bingo

Posted on 08th December 2021 in Employment

A great way to simultaneously raise money for your organisation’s chosen charity and boost workplace morale may be to run a raffle, bingo or similar ‘lottery’, and the current festive period may seem like the perfect time to do so. However, you may find there are unexpected rules you have to comply with.

Posted by

Oliver Kent

Trainee Solicitor