COVID-19 Update: Tozers is providing our usual client services while maintaining the safety of our clients and colleagues. Full update here

Complete the form below to ask us a question or make an enquiry. We’ll get back to you via phone or email as soon as possible.

Insights

Tenancy Deposit protection breach – Case law update

Posted on 21st June 2019 in Property Litigation

Posted by

Josh O’Neill

Trainee Solicitor
Tenancy Deposit protection breach – Case law update

Anyone familiar with residential tenancies will know of the onerous duties placed on landlords to protect deposits taken from tenants. Once the initial window for compliance has passed, you cannot serve a valid Section 21 Notice and are automatically liable for a claim for a minimum of one and maximum of three times the value of the deposit. This is the case even if breach is only a failure to provide prescribed information about the protection scheme.

Recently, the Dartford County Court in Howard v Dalton raised a further issue by deciding that a tenant could receive compensation for each instance of breach. In this case, the failure to protect a deposit and a failure to provide prescribed information were treated as separate breaches, each giving rise to compensation. The result was that the landlord was held liable for a penalty of six times the value of the deposit (£1,745). To compound the landlord’s misery, the same breaches occurred on eight different tenancies, leading to a compensation award in excess of £83,000!

The landlord successfully appealed, with the Judge clarifying that a tenant was only entitled to compensation once for each tenancy. The Court commented that it was inevitable that a landlord who failed to protect the deposit also failed to provide prescribed information and that it was not the intention of Parliament to award a separate compensation in those instances.

As a County Court decision, this is not binding on future cases. However, it is likely to be persuasive and does provide some comfort in future cases of multiple breaches. Remember however that some breach(es) on multiple tenancies will still cost you dear so make sure that your processes (or those of your letting/managing agent) are correct and reliable.

For more information on how Tozers can assist you in your lettings, please contact a member of the Property Litigation team on 01392 207020.

 
 

Company & Industry

Related Insights

Insights

Finance and Property deputy role changes

Posted on 22nd January 2021 in Later Life Planning

If you are acting as a deputy for finance and property you may have some questions about your role and what you need to do.

Posted by

Emma Ruttley

Solicitor
Insights

What to do if family mediation is unsuccessful

Posted on 22nd January 2021 in Family Law

If progress is not being made, or if mediation breaks down or perhaps mediation was not deemed suitable for the parties at the initial intake session, then the parties should speak to their solicitors about the other options available to them.

Posted by

Aimee Aspinall

Chartered Legal Executive