Covid-19 Update: We are continuing to provide our usual services whilst maintaining the safety of clients and colleagues. Read our latest update here.

Complete the form below to ask us a question or make an enquiry. We’ll get back to you via phone or email as soon as possible.

Insights

The problem of confusingly similar trade marks

Posted on 13th May 2015 in Intellectual Property

Posted by

Jill Headford

Partner and Solicitor
The problem of confusingly similar trade marks

Once a trade mark is registered, others will be prevented from registering a confusingly similar mark for the same or similar services.  This poses a problem for a business with a similar name who also wish to register it. 

The time honoured way around the problem of similar existing registered marks is to incorporate the name into a logo in order to make it sufficiently distinctive. However, a recent decision in a European Court shows that this will not always work.

The case concerned frozen food manufacturing company, Iglotex SA, who appealed a decision by the EU to reject their application to register ‘Iglotex’ because it was too similar to an existing trade mark of another frozen food company called ‘Iglo’.

Iglo’s mark was made up of just the word Iglo, whilst Iglotex’s mark included Iglotex + a penguin + a snowflake. Iglotex argued that these distinct elements made their logo sufficiently different. The court rejected this argument for the following reasons:

  • the new elements must be key characteristics of the mark if it is otherwise similar to an existing registered mark. The penguin and snowflake were not key characteristics.
  • the public could confuse Iglotex with Iglo because they sounded and looked similar.
  • consumers were likely to pay the most attention to the first part of a word because it has the most phonetic impact. Therefore just adding ‘tex’ onto the end of “Iglo” would not sufficiently differentiate the marks

Iglotex had presumably spent a lot of money on developing their new logo given that they were willing to go to such lengths in an attempt to register it.

It is crucial when choosing a product name to ensure that it is sufficiently different from names already in use for similar goods or services. Your research should always include a search of existing names.

Company & Industry

Related Insights

Insights

Maternity wards still not improved despite a series of recent scandals

Posted on 21st September 2021 in Medical Negligence

Care Qualify Commission has voiced concern that mothers’ and babies are being put at risk of injury and death because too many maternity units have not improved.

Posted by

Simon Mansfield

Partner and Solicitor
Insights

Digital Lasting Power of Attorneys

Posted on 20th September 2021 in Later Life Planning

A more straightforward digital system to set up a Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) could come into play, but experts say that it is vital that sufficient safeguards are in place to protect elderly and vulnerable people from abuse. In this article, we look at how the system might work, and the concerns for potential abuse of a digital process for setting up Lasting Power of Attorney.

Posted by

Gráinne Staunton

Partner and Solicitor