Complete the form below to ask us a question or make an enquiry. We’ll get back to you via phone or email as soon as possible.

Insights

Fewer epidurals - fewer ventouse and forceps deliveries?

Posted on 09th May 2023 in Medical Negligence

Posted by

Clair Hemming

Partner and Solicitor
Fewer epidurals - fewer ventouse and forceps deliveries?

In new draft guidelines for the NHS, NICE is recommending remifentanil be offered to women in labour for pain relief as an alternative to an epidural, and says that the advantages include more mobility during labour and might lead to fewer births using instruments like forceps and ventouse.

NICE (National Institute for Clinical Excellence) is a public body that provide national guidance and advice to improve health and social care.    

Is remifentanil an alternative to an epidural?

There is a range of pain relief options available in labour, but an epidural is a popular choice as it is usually very effective and can last several hours.  It does have side effects and as it involves a spinal injection it is a significant procedure that can take time to set up, but it is generally thought to be safe.

One of the downsides to an epidural is that it causes numbness in the lower body so that women cannot walk around during labour and are often confined to the bed. Also, the inability to feel the sensations of labour can hinder a woman in delivering her baby herself, and some suggest that it increases the prospect of needing instruments such as forceps or a ventouse.

Although entirely safe when used correctly, forceps and ventouse instruments can cause injuries to the newborn baby and also to the mother.  Unfortunately, in assisting those bringing medical negligence claims arising from childbirth, we in the clinical negligence team at Tozers see these all too frequently.

How does remifentanil work?

The new draft guidelines for “Intrapartum care for healthy women and babies” recommend that remifentanil which is a fast acting morphine-like drug, now be offered to women in labour. This is administered into a vein and can be controlled by the women herself, with a timer which prevents overuse. It is reported to be a strong pain killer that provides quick, short pain relief within 20 – 30 seconds and wears off in minutes.

Like all medication, it can have side effects, but experts suggest that remifentanil is safe and effective.  It is however not available in all maternity units at present.

Time will tell if remifentanil will deliver what is promised, and there is certainly some debate on this by obstetric and midwifery commentators. However more options for pain relief so that women in labour can choose what is right for them and their baby is welcomed.

How we can help

If you or your family have suffered because of medical negligence, we will help you to recover appropriate compensation and secure the future. 

Contact our legal experts

Company & Industry

Related Insights

Insights

Preventable Tragedies: 56 Babies and 2 Mothers Lost at Leeds Teaching Hospital

Posted on 20th January 2025 in Medical Negligence

Over the past few years, maternity units across England have been investigated due to concerns over failing care and poor patient safety. This has resulted in Donna Ockenden, a British midwife and community activist, undertaking independent reviews across various Trusts, to provide families with answers and aim for improvement in outcomes for both babies and mothers.   

Posted by

Helena Campbell

Associate & Chartered Legal Executive
Insights

Stop the Pressure Campaign: Highlighting the Importance of Prevention

Posted on 20th November 2024 in Medical Negligence

In support of the Stop The Pressure campaign, we're helping to raise awareness of pressure injuries, in the hope of reducing the number of avoidable pressure wounds. In the UK, over 700,000 people are affected by pressure ulcers each year. Of these, 180,000 are newly acquired, 60% of which occur in people over the age of 70. We shine some light on the issue in our latest insight.

Posted by

Helena Campbell

Associate & Chartered Legal Executive