Complete the form below to ask us a question or make an enquiry. We’ll get back to you via phone or email as soon as possible.


Patient given wrong medicine for surgery

Posted on 23rd June 2021 in Medical Negligence

Posted by

Endurance Arthur

Partner and Solicitor
Patient given wrong medicine for surgery

It was reported that in 2018 a hospital drug mix up meant a 77 year old lady from Plymouth, Devon, was wide awake during her heart surgery at Derriford Hospital. Patricia Otty said, “I was wide awake during my heart surgery”.

It turned out she was given the Death Row lethal injection ingredient, this meant she became paralysed so there was no way of her to communicate with the surgeons, this was caused by the muscle relaxant rocuronium, The painkiller fentanyl was not given at all, so Ms Otty was in agony.

When her heart stopped as a result of the wrong drug being given, she had to be resuscitated, by which point any anaesthetic she had in her system had worn off. She was given half the usual dose of the general anaesthetic thiopentone for a woman of her age and size.

Since the operation took place, Ms Otty was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), she regularly suffers from nightmares where she is choking and experiencing excruciating pain. She said she 'implicitly' recalls the procedure, but cannot explicitly remember because of the effects of a sleeping pill.

As a result of this a £32,000 settlement was agreed by University Hospitals Plymouth NHS Trust. The Trust has admitted breaching its duty of care in 2018 over the wrongful administration of the medicine, it has made 11 learning recommendations. They said, 'We're truly sorry, nobody should go through an experience like this. That's why we accepted liability and made the payment.'

Tozers’ medical law specialist Stuart Bramley observes –

“Anaesthetic awareness claims are unusual now, although sadly much more commonplace a decade or so ago. Much-welcomed improvements in monitoring the patent during surgery have been introduced so the sort of agony Patricia Otty underwent at Plymouth are thankfully now rare

That of course doesn’t diminish how dreadful this experience must have been for her. Any surgical procedure would be painful without anaesthesia; but an open-heart operation like this will have seemed terrifying when Ms Otty also lacked the ability to communicate with the staff.  It is to the hospital’s credit that as well as paying her the compensation she so clearly deserves, they have also issued an unreserved apology and taken steps to avoid a recurrence. I do hope this is the last such incident I read about”.

If you or your family have suffered because of medical negligence, we’ll help you to rebuild your life for the future. Contact us today and let us help you.

Contact our legal experts


Paper plane


Get the latest news straight from our legal experts.

Subscribe to our newsletter to recieve current, dedicated, suppport and guidance from our solicitors straight to your inbox, wherever you are.


Company & Industry

Related Insights


Hypoxic Ischemic Encephalopathy – A Parent’s Experience

Posted on 04th April 2024 in Medical Negligence

For many years we at Tozers have supported families affected by Hypoxic Ischemic Encephalopathy (HIE). HIE is a type of brain damage which is caused by a lack of oxygen to the brain before or shortly after birth. We assist families to bring a claim for compensation where their child has developed physical and/or cognitive difficulties. 

Posted by

Clair Hemming

Partner and Solicitor

The Implementation of Martha’s Rule

Posted on 22nd February 2024 in Medical Negligence

On World Sepsis Day 2023, I wrote an article raising awareness of this devastating illness, and shared the work being courageously undertaken by Martha’s parents, after Martha sadly and avoidably lost her life to sepsis at just 13 years old.

Posted by

Helena Campbell

Associate & Chartered Legal Executive